Breaking News

Govt Enforces ‘Melt and Pour’ Rule for All Steel in Public Projects Nippon Steel expected to finalize U.S. Steel acquisition at $55 per share NMDC Limited reports a 38% drop in Q4 FY24 consolidated net profit RINL to Raise $23 Million Through Land Sales Amid Crisis

SC allows ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel, IOC to appoint arbitrators in Essar case

640285_1707721659_small.jpeg
Business 12 Feb 2024 12:37 PM IST Live Mint

Indian Oil Corp (IOC) and ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel (AMNS) can each designate an arbitrator within a week to settle their disagreement over Essar Steel, the Supreme Court said on Monday.

The apex court also set aside the October ruling of the Delhi high court which had rejected IOC's plea for the appointment of an arbitral tribunal to settle its claims.

According to the top court's directive, the nominated arbitrators will need to appoint a third arbitrator to complete the formation of the arbitral tribunal. 

On Friday, AMNS and IOC informed the apex court that they had mutually agreed to appoint arbitrators to settle all disputes. The two parties had also urged the court to set aside the Delhi High Court's ruling in the case.

The dispute traces back to a conflict over a gas supply agreement (GSA) in 2009 between IOC and the then Essar Steel India (ESIL), which AMNS acquired after a corporate insolvency resolution process in 2019. IOC had challenged the termination of the agreement by Essar Steel in 2017, demanding dues, which led to an arbitration invocation when Essar failed to respond.

On August 2, 2017, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) in Ahmedabad admitted ESIL into insolvency proceedings based on pleas by the State Bank of India and Standard Chartered. IOC lodged a claim of over ₹3,500 crore with the appointed resolution professional (RP), but the RP only admitted the claim for a notional value of ₹1. The Committee of Creditors (CoC) of Essar Steel accepted Arcelor Mittal's resolution plan, which was approved by the NCLT on March 8, 2019.

The legal dispute escalated when the NCLT disagreed with the RP's decision regarding the admission of claims, including IOCs, at a nominal value of ₹1. Appeals were made in the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), but similar decisions were reached. Eventually, the Supreme Court overturned the rulings of the NCLT and NCLAT, allowing the RP's actions and approving AMNS' resolution plan. ArcelorMittal acquired 100% of Essar Steel India's shares on December 16, 2019.

After the resolution plan was implemented, IOC sought payment as per the terms of the GSA. ArcelorMittal denied IOC's claim, leading the oil company to invoke arbitration by serving notice to ArcelorMittal to appoint an arbitrator. However, AMNS remained unresponsive, prompting the IOC to approach the Delhi High Court.

In October 2023, the Delhi High Court dismissed IOC's plea because once the resolution process has been completed and the resolution plan approved, no fresh claims can be laid against the successful resolution applicant.

The high court ruled that the dispute sought in the current case could not be reintroduced before the arbitral tribunal, as it had already acknowledged the acceptance of the resolution plan as final. Allowing the petition would effectively imply a reopening of the resolution plan, making the issues raised by IOC unsuitable for arbitration.